3 best hotels in New York on a budget
Sample dates 2026-12-11 → 2026-12-13, 1 adult. Refreshed daily.
New York on a budget usually means staying near Long Island City and Midtown West. Instead of a list of 300 hotels, here are the three that scored best today.
Arlo Midtown is the closest to Midtown West at 700 m. The average guest rating across the three is 8.7/10. Totals for 2 nights run from $1,422 to $2,084 ($711–$1,042 a night).
#1Arlo Midtown
4-star · 700 m from Midtown West
$1,422total · 2 nights
8.7(7,177)
- 700 m from Midtown West, rated 8.7/10 by 7,177 guests.
- $1,014 over your budget for the stay.
#2The Knickerbocker Hotel
5-star · 1.1 km from Midtown West
$2,084total · 2 nights
8.7(3,617)
- 1.2 km from Midtown West, rated 8.7/10 by 3,617 guests.
- $1,676 over your budget for the stay.
#3citizenM New York Times Square
4-star · 1.1 km from Midtown West
$1,714total · 2 nights
8.7(4,703)
- 1.1 km from Midtown West, rated 8.7/10 by 4,703 guests.
- $1,306 over your budget for the stay.
Different dates or budget?
Get your own three picks for New York in four taps.
How we chose these three
Each stay is scored on four things: a guest rating smoothed by review count, fit with a $0–$204 per-night band, distance to Long Island City and Midtown West, and a small partner-commission term capped so it never outranks quality. We then pick three that differ in neighbourhood and price. The "why" and the drawback under each hotel use only fields the booking partner returned.
Questions travellers ask
- How much does a hotel in New York cost on a budget?
- For these dates, our three picks total $1,422–$2,084 for 2 nights, which is $711–$1,042 a night for 1 adult.
- Which New York hotel is closest to Midtown West?
- Of the three, Arlo Midtown is the closest at 700 m from Midtown West.
- How many guests are these New York prices for?
- Prices are for 1 adult, the default we use for a budget trip. You can change dates on the booking page.